Freedom

BRUCE LEE, MY BROTHER Review

by James Marsh, November 22, 2010 4:58 AM


Who wouldn't want to see a biopic about the early life of Bruce Lee? Nearly 40 years after his death, Lee remains not only the most influential screen martial artist of all time, but the world's most famous Asian actor, period. Lee's trademark shriek, yellow jumpsuit & scratched face and torso made him a cultural icon of the 20th Century. His untimely death in 1973 at the age of just 32 only served to add to his mystique. However, while millions of fans have watched and re-watched his five kung-fu movies, quoted them ad infinitum and probably attempted to re-enact a sequence or two, Lee's early life, along with the dozens of films he made as a child & teenager, is considerably less well known. What directors Raymond Yip and Manfred Wong set out to do in their new film, BRUCE LEE, MY BROTHER is shed some light on who Bruce Lee was before he became a legend.   


Based on the memoir written by Lee's younger brother, Robert, the film begins with Bruce's birth in San Francisco, while his father, Lee Hoi Cheun (played by Tony Leung Ka Fai), was touring the USA with his Cantonese Opera troupe. We see the accidental way in which Lee acquired his English name, and also star in his first movie - GOLDEN GATE GIRL - while still a newborn. Against the advice of his friends, Lee Sr. whisks his family back to Hong Kong, only to see the city invaded by the Japanese shortly thereafter.  Lee was the fourth of five children and grew up in a comfortably well-off household, thanks in large part to his father's success as an actor on both stage and screen. It didn't take long for young Bruce to begin appearing in local productions, and by the age of six had landed his first starring role and acquired the stage name Lee Siu Long - "Little Dragon" - the name he would use throughout his career.

The film chronicles Lee's life up to the age of 18 and his return to America, which in turn paved the way for the greater things yet to come. Lee (played by Aarif Rahman) is depicted as cocky, confident and somewhat mischievous, whose involvement in street fights, petty crime and vandalism regularly incur the wrath of his strict father. While certainly a handsome youth, Lee was apparently not much of a ladies man. He has his fans, but is besotted by his best friend's girl, Pearl (Jennifer Tse) - a problem that sees him more often pouting like a scolded puppy dog rather than sewing his oats in local nightclubs. And this hints at the problems inherent within BRUCE LEE, MY BROTHER because, for all the potentially exciting, tumultuous and life-changing events that are going on around these characters, not a great deal actually happens in the film.

Raymond Yip served as co-director of THE WARLORDS alongside Peter Chan, and Manfred Wong's regular collaborations with Andrew Lau have proved them both to be competent and hugely cinematic filmmakers. They bring a rich and vibrant look to the film, whether during the intimate scenes within the gorgeous wood-panelled confines of the Lee family home, or grandstanding with beautiful street sets or CG-enhanced vistas of 1950s Hong Kong. As a result, BRUCE LEE, MY BROTHER is never less than gorgeous to look at. The problem lies in the fact that whether depicting the Japanese occupation, the uneasy years afterwards as the British regained control and the city slowly began to recover, or even the day-to-day misadventures of a young teenager who also happened to be a local movie star, the film is stupefyingly boring.

We see nothing of Lee coping, or struggling with the success and stardom he acquired at a very young age, his brawling and other misdemeanors have no real consequences, his love life is a perpetual non-starter because of his infatuation with Pearl and his home life is equally uneventful. Because our narrator, Robert Lee, was so young during these years, he was understandably kept mostly in the dark about his father's opium habit, financial pressures from corrupt officials, or even more infuriatingly - pretty much anything of interest that occurred during Bruce's adolescence.

As a result, the film can do little more than meander from one non-event to the next. That is, until someone behind the scenes' patience obviously snapped and the final reel inexplicably turns into a Donnie Yen movie. Out of nowhere a brash, loudmouthed English boxer appears on the scene and challenges Lee to a fight. At the same time, Lee's best friend gets involved in drugs and must be rescued from a foreboding squat house, and where there was nothing remotely interesting happening for an hour and a half, there is suddenly a melee of duels, rematches and rooftop run-ins with drug dealers. But by that stage it is all too little too late.

As with the recent onslaught of Ip Man films from Wilson Yip and Herman Yau, there is yet again a reluctance to actually depict the Grand Master's tutelage of Lee on-screen. In this case, the audience never even gets to see Ip Man's face, and so whatever last remaining fibre of hope you may have been clinging to for this movie to be in any way entertaining, slips through your fingers. And what makes this film all the more annoying is that it is filled with almost uniformly excellent performances.

Tony Leung Ka Fai is excellent as Lee Hoi Cheun, making a complex and contradictory character sympathetic and likable when he could have easily depicted him as a drug-addled tyrant. Christy Chung returns to our screens for the first time in 6 years and is delightfully tender as Bruce's long-suffering mother. There's also solid support from Michelle Ye and MC Jin. The real praise, however, goes to relative newcomer Aarif Rahman who does a fantastic job as Bruce Lee. Rahman goes far beyond mere imitation, totally embodying the Little Dragon onscreen and perfectly capturing that balance between cock-sure and charismatic that was so integral to what made Lee such a commanding screen presence.

It would be fantastic if Media Asia was able to acquire the necessary rights and permissions to continue the Bruce Lee story, because with this cast and production crew in place, surely they couldn't fail to make an engaging and thrilling drama out of the second half of his life. As it stands, however, BRUCE LEE, MY BROTHER is little more than an ornately decorated vessel - that looks great, sounds great, yet contains almost nothing of real interest. 


6 Comments

user-pic

Not to worry -- I'm sure eight million other Lee biopics/cash-ins will be out in due time, maybe one of those will be better. This frankly awful-looking thing is due out in the mainland just two days later.

the five points of vurtue.sighn out

user-pic

"the film is stupefyingly boring."


"As a result, the film can do little more than meander from one non-event to the next"

So obviously this moron of an author thinks the movie is boring and that nothing happens from one non-event to the next. This means that he thinks that when a gang of punks come chasing after you and you have no means of escape, it's pretty boring (that must be a daily event for him). He must also think that his best friends girl hitting on him is also boring (social dilemma's like this must happen to him every day, this author is a stud). As the author thinks the movie is uneventful with one non-event to the next, he must also find that his mother's heart-breaking frustration at him and his siblings to be insignificant (a pretty insensitive son to his own mother, this author must be).

He must also believe that taking up Martial Arts of Gung Fu is a meaningless decision in your life, or that a foreigner picking a fight with you on the street is boring and meaningless (he must be challenged by fighters all the time, this author is really amazing!). Or when, British government invade your home and steal your money, and accuse your father of drug use is really UNEVENTFUL and boring (this author must get visits by the five Oh all the time, he's a real bad ass).
The author is correct, all these things are uneventful: if you're dead inside. Wake the hell up, man. What movie were you watching if you didn't notice these LOUD facts? You would have to be blind to miss all that.. or just dead inside with no feeling- Jaded. The only other one explanation is that these kinds of things are truly insignificant to you, which means you're like Superman!!

And these were just the parts before his big Cha Cha Contest, a public match against a 3x champion, and drug and criminal involvement. Actually these were all AFTER the Japanese invading their home, his father severely disciplining him putting the fear of god into him and even landing into movies. So we didn't even mention all this, just the parts with Araf Ahman, and even cut out the parts of Araf which crescendo at the end!

Given the facts; you've been pointed out as a fool.

(so sad. with THAT faulty perception constantly on, you must not enjoy various good movies.)

user-pic

"moron", "stud", "insensitive son", "really amazing", "a real badass", "dead inside", "blind", "dead inside with no feeling", "jaded", "like Superman", "a fool"

Ryder, I'm confused - did you agree with my opinion or not?

user-pic

Sarcasm is your only defense against the hard FACTS that draw you out?? Hmmm, so original. Most times sarcasm is a sign of weakness my friend. You went thru all the trouble of locating insults and typing them but couldn't even address your own error that was pointed out. Interesting

The insults btw, was just furnishing of the valid points being stated that showed your major error. One can ignore or delete the insults and still see the point standing that cut you down. So I embarrassed you but...you deserved it. Next time open your jaded eyes when you watch a film, or instead THINK before you write. (and the furnishing insults was in good turn for your OWNinsulting attitude that you delivered to the decent film. You invited it pal, HELL ya asked for it)

p.s. everyone's free to have an opinion pal, but opinions don't change facts. Be less spoiled on your expectations of a film, and be more objective in your reviews.

user-pic

Good to see eloquence is alive and kicking on the Internet.


Leave a comment

Related Posts with Thumbnails