The Face of Another

TIFF 2010: 13 ASSASSINS Review

by Kurt Halfyard, September 15, 2010 11:30 AM


13Assassins-still.jpg
Takashi Miike doing Akira Kurosawa? Yes Please! 13 Assassins is not the goofy homage to Sergio(s) Leone and Corbucci that Sukiyaki Django Western was. Japan's most hard to pin down auteur re-invents himself once again to offer a mainstream audience an earnest and restrained look at vintage Samurai cinema with all the honour and fighting against all odds offered by classics like The Seven Samurai. 

Sure Kurosawa's masterpiece did not have amputees or large beasts of burden running on fire, so there are touches of the director in the margins, but mostly you have some of the most handsome cinematography in a Japanese picture in ages, and a scope and scale that is much further beyond what most would expect from a Miike film. How amazing that a director so prolific can manage to keep his pace for surprises! Normally, when oddball auteurs like David Cronenberg or Peter Jackson do a slick studio picture, a small part of me laments for their wilder more uncouth days. In this case, the results are too damn magnificent to ignore.

It is the mid-19th century, and the Shogunate has known peace for many, many years. The Samurai have grown soft and weak in their inactivity (and boredom), many taking to gambling and drinking. A Grand show of seppuku in the beginning moments plays as a release from failure both literal, and some deeper decay in the soul of the country. That decay is a sadistic lord, Naritsugu, who is on the fast track to real power in the Shogunate. His casual killing and raping for sport, enabled by his noble lineage, has forced the more noble (and more political) advisor to the Shogun, Sir Doi, to set a plan in motion to have Naritsug killed on the way from Edo to his own lands, as to proclaim him unfit to rule would have dangerous political ripples. Doi finds one of the last 'old school' Samurai, Shinzaemon, who has been seriously wronged by Naritsugu, to put a small strike team together for the mission. Since Shinzaemon is played by one of the most gifted actors working in Japan (and abroad) today, Koji Yakusho (many are familiar with his many collaborations with Kiyoshi Kurosawa, but he also occasionally steps into prestige western cinema such as Babel or Memoirs of a Geisha), there is a casual gravitas, an intense confidence, brought to the role, not unlike Lee Marvin in The Dirty Dozen. The gathering of 'the team' comprises the first act of the film and consists of finding a few of the remaining competent swordsman that are trust-worthy, and throwing a few wild-cards in there as well, including a hunter who is clearly channeling Toshiro Mifune (albeit it a tad, just a tad goofier). Shinzaemon gambles his stratagems on the psychotic target, but is soon even in more trouble when Naritsugu's lead samurai is both highly competent and an old friendly rival in school. The second act is like a game of Go between the two Samurai leaders, and is a pleasurable appetizer to the main course of "Total Massacre." Fortifying a town as best they can (and they can indeed), the third act is a doozy of a set piece. A siege, an ambush, a slaughter, a war. It is not surprising that Lord Naritsugu is in both awe of the slaughter, and practically cries tears of joy at the whole-sale carnage (even as, or especially as the thirteen are destroying hundreds of his men) This is the director casting us, the audience, as the psychotic in the narrative that enjoys this sort of thing (Michael Haneke is not around for comment), and indulging us at the same time.

The film acquires some welcome weightiness from all the standard genre conventions when you consider the consequences of a selfish psycho calling the shots and fate of honourable men. The film is not afraid of taking the caste system of the Shogunate to task. Yet, even noble Shinzaemon is 'delighted' to be able to engage in war, his purpose, within his lifetime. The crazy odds of the venture seem to excite him all the more. In spite of all the blood, mud and trampled flesh (or maybe because of it) war is exciting, and Miike never lets the audience forget it. 13 Assassins is a gloriously glossy genre picture that gives an impossible and heroic situation all the glory it is due. It is curious to see Miike do something so straight-forward and crowd pleasing. I am sure he will be off to a new picture (or three) which is as different and wacky and unconventional as is his wont. Sit back and enjoy his stop in epic myth making.

At Mubi

11 Comments

user-pic

I would figure it's more like Mikke doing Eiichi Kudo since it is a remake of his movie. Nonetheless, I am looking forward to this one.

user-pic

It is probably wrong to simply label this a 'remake' as 13 Assassins as Miike seems to encapsulate the whole genre with his approach. There are many references to many films (call them cliches or genre conventions, although it never really feels like it while the movie plays...) and it feels like it making an overall statement on why we still love this genre today. Not in an obvious of a way as Inglorious Basterds went for 'power of cinema' and all that, but

I have not seen Eiichi Kudo's original, however, so I really cannot comment or compare.

user-pic

Your review is otherwise fine, but you really let yourself down with your opening. It's incorrect, and misleading. Kurosawa didn't invent the jidaigeki genre, nor did he have anything to do with the film that Miike's is based on.

user-pic

Don, talk to me after you see the film (I am assuming you haven't). I know there are more hardcore and knowledgeable Jidaigeki and Chanbara fans out there, I don't think a review of 13 assassins should be getting into that sort of dick-measuring contest...But for those who have seen the film and do not see the overt, specific, nods to Seven Samurai, well you watched a different film than I...

user-pic

I'm not trying to pull rank on you Kurt or get into a dick-measuring contest. I haven't seen Miike's version yet, so until I do I can't argue your assertion that his film is a homage to Kurosawa. But the only justification you give in your review for your opening statement that Miike is "doing Kurosawa" is that a hunter character (who you don't name, or mention who played him) is "clearly channeling Toshio Mifune." If there really are all these "overt, specific nods" to Seven Samurai, why didn't you include any of them in your review?

user-pic

It never fit into the review because that is how the review fell out. However, after you have seen Miike's film, I am more than happy to have this conversation. who knows, I might have seen the original version of 13 Assassins by then. I can see how the first sentence could get peoples backs up, I didn't intend it to imply that Miike was remaking a Kurosawa film, only that the film he made strongly echoes the work of Kurosawas Chanbara films.

user-pic

Now I've seen the film, I can say in all confidence that Miike was not "doing Kurosawa" at all. I'll admit that Iseya Yusuke's character bares a superficial resemblance to Mifune's in Seven Samurai, but that's where the similarities begin and end. Tengan Daisuke's script is largely faithful to Kudo's version, with some embellishments and alterations. If that makes me a "chanbara elitist" so be it.

After the first sentence, how can i keep reading !? Sounds ridiculous, sorry.

user-pic

Heh. Out of all the things that I thought I might be criticized on, its is this? Who know there were so many Chanbara elitists out there? Either way, 13 Assassins is a rip-roaring film, people should see it whether they think I am an idiot or not! ;)

I'm certainly no chanbara elitists but I did know that Kurosawa didn't direct 13 Assassins. Avg joe movie guy who doesn't follow chanbara films won't know (i fortunately have some knowledge).

Any way, it doesn't matter to me, nice review. I'm glad that he didn't take the Sukiyaki Django route. I purchased a quality fansub of that film after its release and still haven't managed to sit through it. IMO, Miike hasn't made a good film since 'Yakuza Demon' in 2003 (Actually 'Like a Dragon' was ok.)

Either way, Miike's been a complete disappointment for me over past 7 years. Hopefully that'll change with this film.

Yep, reminiscent of Seven Samurai. It was a very good movie but what the hell happened to the ending? *SPOILER ALERT* Koyata Kiga (the hunter) was stabbed through the neck by Naritsugu's (the Lord) short sword and sliced through the middle by Hanbei (the Lord chief samurai), but at the end was running around like a spring rabbit when he caught up with Shinroukuro (the nephew) - WTF???


Leave a comment

Related Posts with Thumbnails