NausicaƤ of the Valley of the Wind

Roman Polanski's The Ghost Writer Review

by Charles Webb, March 20, 2010 1:43 PM


Roman Polanski's latest is an interesting film containing fascinating performances - the problem is that it's not a particularly good thriller.

After the ghost writer of his memoirs washes up on the beach in an apparent suicide, former British Prime Minister Adam Lang (Pierce Brosnan) finds himself in need of a replacement. Enter Ewan Macgregor's unnamed Ghost, who is hired with some trepidation by the publisher, but who has a reputation for objectivity and most importantly, working fast - which is good, because the way things are looking for Lang, the PM may soon be sitting in a cell for war crimes.

Of course, being a Ghost, the writer attempts to remain outside of the increasingly messy events of Lang's life - above and beyond the story.But his very presence near the PM sweeps the Ghost up unwillingly into the mysterious death of the latter's predecessor and a very real fear for his own life.

It should be said that the movie doesn't lack for terrific, textured performances (save for one). As the Ghost, Macgregor plays a refinement of the smartass persona that he's projected over the last 15 years of roles. He's the guy who would much rather be doing anything but getting involved. As Lang, Brosnan also plays a variation on some of his more recent roles: Tony Blair by way of his perfomances in films like The Matador and The Tailor of Panama. Lang is a charmer who's secretly afraid he's an empty suit. With his memoirs, Lang is desperately attempting to control the image of himself he leaves for history. Olivia Williams is the standout as Lang's wife, Ruth who sees the crumbling of her husband's reputation as the imminent death of their marriage. She's the keeper of secrets and it's clear that without Lang she's unsure who she'll be. Even Jim Belushi has a small but effective role as a gruff publisher, convincing me someone needs to write a script with him as the heavy ASAP.

Unfortunately, Kim Cattrall is awful in nearly every scene she's in, with an inconsistent British accent and a plastic performance that at first seems intentional and later feels like the only dimension she's capable to bringing to the character.

I mentioned that The Ghost Writer is not an effective thriller - when the movie focuses on its characters it crackles with energy but the scenes where the Ghost is dragged into the plot outside the plot almost seem perfunctory. I dislike these segments of the movie because they pull MacGregor and Brosnan apart for large parts of the runtime, much to the production's detriment. Worse and more importantly, the big reveal at the core of the film is telegraphed midway through, and when it ultimately comes to light it's in such a silly, contrived manner that had me chuckling when it should not have.

More importantly, the mystery makes the story feel small - not intimate, just built with a very narrow view of evil in this world. It's a view that palpably needs a conspiracy to justify acts of evil. In its resolution of the mystery it reaches all kinds of talking points about military-industrial complex without saying anything particularly compelling.  

One other odd note: there's some conspicuous audio looping for profanity to get the film to its PG-13 rating here in the U.S.. It's not a huge thing but it's kind of distracting.        



7 Comments

Wow, you nailed it. This film is a letdown across the board.

user-pic

Nah guys. This film is a masterpiece of genre cinema. Sure the overall conspiracy feels rather cliche, but Polanski is firing on all his Hitchcockian cylinders and it had me grinning the entire time. The film is so wonderfully self-aware that its easy to forgive the contrivances and just enjoy impeccably crafted ride.

Its just honest to goodness, classic pulp filmmaking at its finest.

user-pic

I'm with you, I caught it last night and thought it was superb. A wonderful Hitchcock pastiche that has more in common with North By Northwest than other modern thrillers, from the score to the quirky bit parts. I found any plot contrivance/silliness was swept away by the sheer joy of watching such an old-fashioned, well made piece of cinema. Cattrall was terrible, granted, but the others just about made up for it. I thought at first Ewan McGregor's English accent would bother me but I quickly didin't notice it.

user-pic

>>Peter: I'd tend to agree with you if the central mystery didn't feel like it was attempting to convey a capital "m" message about the relationship between the U.S. and the U.K..

Watching it I couldn't help thinking of another Polanski misfire, "The Ninth Gate" which was also rich with atmosphere and performances and also faltered terribly in the final act.

user-pic

I love the Ninth Gate. Batshit-Terrible-Sort-of-Crazy ending and all.

For me Ghost Writer has a bland, even more terrible ending, but it was fun to spot some weird self-critical moments of Polanski in the text. The 'what the hey' sex with Ruth, the extradition stuff. Fun. But the film is probably a little too old-school and not sufficiently original to be more than minor Polanski. There was certainly an ingredient missing, not a lot of tension in the movie, and a tad to straight-forward.

I agree that the performances were good, but Jim Belushi and Eli Wallach were distracting in their scenes because both of them seemed rather 'random' in their casting and non-importance in the movie.

user-pic

I was not aware they finally arrested him, he was in France and they would not expidate him back to America to face the charges for his crime.
Joliese Tan

user-pic

>> Nasharti: He hasn't been extradited yet - if I recall he's still awaiting extradition in Switzerland.


Leave a comment

Related Posts with Thumbnails