No Country for Old Men

BODYGUARDS AND ASSASSINS: Review

by Niels Matthijs, March 8, 2010 6:00 AM


Ever since the success of "Hero" and "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon", China and Hong Kong have been upping the productions scales of their flagship films little by little. Over a period of 10 years time they've succeeded in producing subsequently bigger and more epic films. The latest to join the group is Bodyguards And Assassins, a welcome variation on the big budget martial arts film.

How he did it, I really don't know, but director Teddy Chan raised enough money to completely rebuild the old center of Hong Kong as one insanely large set piece. It's difficult to say whether it really paid off (considering the equally insane amount of money it must have cost), but the result is certainly lavish to behold. The incredibly detailed reconstruction of the old center of the city is so much more entertaining than whatever CG graphic they could've slapped on instead.

Even though Bodyguards And Assassins falls roughly into the same category of films as Hero, The Banquet, Fearless and last year's Ip Man, its focus lies not so much on action but on retelling the events around the start of the Chinese revolution. No doubt an extremely important event in Chinese history, but I'm sure not many people in the West (including me) will know about the ins and outs. The trailers might have you believe otherwise, but the film is really not a full-on action movie and Chan takes his time to ensure the film is more than a simple martial arts film set against historic events.

Bodyguards And Assassins is constructed around the arrival of Sun Yat-Sen, a key figure in the revolution against the empire. As he is about the set foot in Hong Kong to meet the 13 district representatives, plans are plotted to get him assassinated. A group of rebels is ready to meet their destiny trying to protect Sun at whatever cost, guaranteeing the success of his mission. There's not too much room for subtlety but considering the epic proportions of this film, it's not something I expected in the first place.

There's a very clear division between the first and second part of the film. Chan uses the time before the arrival to introduce all the characters related to the events. The whole first part is virtually void of any action and relies on the characters and the drama surrounding their mission. While this is far from boring, it does become a little too melodramatic at times. Once Sun arrives the second part of the film kicks off, shifting gears and playing like one massive action scene.

The detailed and elaborate sets makes sure there is plenty to enjoy on a visual level. The scenes on the street of Hong Kong are simply amazing. Still it feels as if Chan didn't make full use of what he had in his hands. I wouldn't have minded if the city had featured a little more prominently, now Chan is a little quick to cut away from some scenes. The camera work too is a little too slick, especially during the first half. The music suffers similar problems.

As for the actors, not only production values seem to be rising, there's also a trend of cramming in as many familiar faces as possible. The cast is almost as impressive as the set, with Simon Yam, Eric Tsang, Tony Leung Ka Fai, Donnie Yen, Fan Bing Bing and Leon Lai on the team. Still nothing compared to the cast of Founding Of A Republic, but an impressive list of actors nonetheless. It is ironic though that the best performance in the film is delivered by none of the above, but by the relatively unknown Xueqi Wang. Even though his character is rather flat and boring, he brings him to life which such apparent ease and style that the man deserves at least some kind of recognition for his role.

For those of you that have trouble sitting through an hour of non-action, rest assured that the second part of the film has some very strong and raw action scenes in store. Yen is put to good use here, though his role remains rather small. Leon Lai has some cool scenes too as enigmatic martial arts master, but it remains a little strange to see him like this. The bad guys are equally impressive and form a believable threat to the heroes, putting on display some mean moves and behavior.

Teddy Chan made a good choice when he decided to split the action and drama so rigidly. It gives you plenty of time to sink into the whole setting, easing you into one long action trip at the end. As for the presentation, there is plenty to enjoy though the feeling remains that a different director could've made more of it. It might be a little disappointing considering what it could've been, on the other hand there are some truly stunning and impressive scenes to be enjoyed here.

I don't know how long they can keep up this trend. Looking at Bodyguards And Assassins and Founding Of A Republic, it's hard to image how they are going to top the scale of these films. But as long as they keep making them as impressive as this, I have little to complain about. Recommended if you've been enjoying the epic productions of the previous decade.

At Mubi

10 Comments

user-pic

Forgive me, but I just don't share the same flowery praise for this movie. To describe it as 1 hour of story and 1 hour of action is incredibly misleading. It's 2 hours of very long-winded, sleep-inducing storyline with a couple very sub-par fight scenes thrown in. I found myself rewinding portions of the movie and watching again because the story made little sense and if you looked away for even a minute you might as well just start the whole thing over again. Just hard to follow and by the time the credits start rolling you're just thankful that it's over. Completely forgettable movie. Horrible CGI blood-spurts. Horrible fake-bald heads giving everyone that huge cranium look. I mean seriously, is it that hard to get actors to actually shave their heads for a movie role? Cung Le looked like he was suffering from some sort of head fracture or something. It was ridiculous...lol.

user-pic

I agree with Petey. I find this a lousy and overrated film. It has max 15 min of action in the film. No more.

I dug the film. Sure it wasn't action-heavy as the trailers led us all to believe, but it made up for it with character and exposition. The movie makes us care for the characters so much, it makes the second half much more tense and bittersweet. Petey, what's not to get about the story? It's about as straightforward as it gets. As far as I'm concerned, why should anyone be concerned about scrutinizing every minute detail instead of kicking back and enjoying the movie?

user-pic

A bit of inconsistent character development but that aside, the movie was rich with emotions, logical plot points and filmmaking values (cinematography, art direction, sets, music etc). Loved the characters of Donnie Yen (despite not having enough fights, his acting made up for that and has truly improved now), Wang Xue-Qi, Tony Leung Ka-Fai, and Hu Jun. They carried the whole movie.

user-pic

I do not agree that it was delved up to two parts. I read this same sentiment over at LoveHKFilm. It was a drama with some actiion throughout the first hour, and more throughout the second hour.

I was quite moved by the acting. The only slow point was Donnie Yen's character longing for his daughter.

Every character was protrayed wonderfully. I wish I could see it on the big screen.

user-pic

Hmmm, it sounds like people expect different things from "action"

There might not be too many fights in the second part, but to me it's still one big action rush. Running through the streets, the Donnie Yen fight, The Leon Lai fight, the Chinese dragons, the scene with the horse (awesome!) , the chase ... Not typical one-on-one martial arts battles, but still plenty of action if you ask me.

user-pic

I just remember turning to my friend and asking "where did the horse go?"

user-pic

I was surprised to find fans of this movie, it was a big disappointment for me.

It was overly sentimental, it felt like the movie was trying to force me into feeling something by making all these characters I don't care for cry and reminisce before their inevitable deaths (it reminded me of the Metal Gear Solid games where every boss character would tell your character about their sad life and shit on their last breath).

I almost lost it when Leon Lai cried over a woman, and most of my friends occupying the same row laughed out loud too. Worse still that wasn't the only time a supposedly emotional moment was met with a derisive reaction, they laughed out loud again during Nicolas Tse's death, it reminded them of Invisible Target.

Don't get me started on the action sequences near the end of the movie. Badly choreographed, poorly shot and sequenced, and horribly edited. Jeez.

Only dudes who cared about this movie (from where I came from at least) were the hardcore China nationalists, which is ironic considering I'm not even in China.

user-pic

You're not alone. I was at the Hong Kong premiere (with director Teddy Chen & others in attendence) and whenever Leon Lai came on screen the entire audience just laughed openly at him.

user-pic

I didn't like it at all. I felt Donnie Yen was wasted in this movie and that's the only reason I watched it.


Leave a comment

Related Posts with Thumbnails