Johnnie To is one of the more productive directors among my list of favorites, which is a good thing as the films he's made these last five years have been of remarkable quality. His latest film Vengeance continues his
winning streak and makes it clearer than ever that To effectively
reinvented himself these last ten years to become a true author.
Vengeance is a little different though. His regular cast is still very much present (Anthony Wong, Suet Lam, Simon Yam), but the lead role is reserved for someone else this time. Johnny Hallyday, famed French singer and occasional actor is the main man this time, lending the film a very specific direction. A pretty daring move, but one that works well.
Hallyday's inclusion raises a pretty big language issue, as Hallyday is a native French speaker while the rest of them speaks Cantonese. Middle ground for both parties is English, spoken with rather fat accents. To handles it well though. I actually don't mind bad English and stilted dialogues if they feel real enough (opposed to say an entire Japanese cast trying to exclaim complex English dialogue for no reason at all). It's personal preference of course, but I'm glad To didn't decide to dub Hallyday in Cantonese, opting for a more realistic approach. It even adds some charm to the film.
The story, like in most of To's films, is rather simple. A basic revenge tale with a couple of twists and turns hurling the film forward. Grandpa Costello travels to Hong Kong after his daughter's family is murdered. His daughter barely survives and demands revenge. After some meager attempts Costello realizes he needs locals to help him out, so when he runs into the group run by Anthony Wong he hires them to do the job for him. Like I said, pretty basic stuff.
To makes sure to put his visual stamp on Vengeance. Brooding slow-motion, dark corners, lots of posing and scarred faces. It's all here again. It has become a crucial element for his films, which thrive on the tension created between two opposing fractions. It's amazing what he can accomplish with a floating camera, tempo changes and two groups of people standing in front of each other.
The soundtrack is not as quirky or as present as in his previous films. It almost seems as if To was scared to surprise his audience with his somewhat atypical choice of music, especially for a film with a broader international appeal. Vengeance is rather silent, but it works well with the slow motion and dark images dreamed up. Acting is as solid as you can expect from the To regulars, even Hallyday puts in a fitting performance. Yam has a pretty small role this time, but Anthony Wong en Suet Lam fans will find enough screen time for both to look forward to.
All that said, if there's anything that defines To these last couple of years it's the addition of certain funny, frivolous elements, granting his films a level of vitality and quirkiness completely absent in comparable films. Somehow it underlines To's love for cinema, and Vengeance doesn't escape from his signature style. Some lovely details (like the bike, the kite-like thing and the stickers) liven up the film without actually hurting the dark atmosphere.
Vengeance is a film that will do well with most Johnnie To fans. There's a chance that the use of different languages will put some people off, or maybe To's playful side will come as a surprise, but apart from that Vengeance is another shining star on To's ever-growing repertoire. A very solid film in all departments, allowing you to sink back into your couch and let the film drift over you like a warm, dark blanket.
Vengeance is a little different though. His regular cast is still very much present (Anthony Wong, Suet Lam, Simon Yam), but the lead role is reserved for someone else this time. Johnny Hallyday, famed French singer and occasional actor is the main man this time, lending the film a very specific direction. A pretty daring move, but one that works well.
Hallyday's inclusion raises a pretty big language issue, as Hallyday is a native French speaker while the rest of them speaks Cantonese. Middle ground for both parties is English, spoken with rather fat accents. To handles it well though. I actually don't mind bad English and stilted dialogues if they feel real enough (opposed to say an entire Japanese cast trying to exclaim complex English dialogue for no reason at all). It's personal preference of course, but I'm glad To didn't decide to dub Hallyday in Cantonese, opting for a more realistic approach. It even adds some charm to the film.
The story, like in most of To's films, is rather simple. A basic revenge tale with a couple of twists and turns hurling the film forward. Grandpa Costello travels to Hong Kong after his daughter's family is murdered. His daughter barely survives and demands revenge. After some meager attempts Costello realizes he needs locals to help him out, so when he runs into the group run by Anthony Wong he hires them to do the job for him. Like I said, pretty basic stuff.
To makes sure to put his visual stamp on Vengeance. Brooding slow-motion, dark corners, lots of posing and scarred faces. It's all here again. It has become a crucial element for his films, which thrive on the tension created between two opposing fractions. It's amazing what he can accomplish with a floating camera, tempo changes and two groups of people standing in front of each other.
The soundtrack is not as quirky or as present as in his previous films. It almost seems as if To was scared to surprise his audience with his somewhat atypical choice of music, especially for a film with a broader international appeal. Vengeance is rather silent, but it works well with the slow motion and dark images dreamed up. Acting is as solid as you can expect from the To regulars, even Hallyday puts in a fitting performance. Yam has a pretty small role this time, but Anthony Wong en Suet Lam fans will find enough screen time for both to look forward to.
All that said, if there's anything that defines To these last couple of years it's the addition of certain funny, frivolous elements, granting his films a level of vitality and quirkiness completely absent in comparable films. Somehow it underlines To's love for cinema, and Vengeance doesn't escape from his signature style. Some lovely details (like the bike, the kite-like thing and the stickers) liven up the film without actually hurting the dark atmosphere.
Vengeance is a film that will do well with most Johnnie To fans. There's a chance that the use of different languages will put some people off, or maybe To's playful side will come as a surprise, but apart from that Vengeance is another shining star on To's ever-growing repertoire. A very solid film in all departments, allowing you to sink back into your couch and let the film drift over you like a warm, dark blanket.


agreed! i thought it was absolutely brilliant. full of fantastic set pieces (bike, hay blocks, sticker flags etc..) loved the pacing, the visual flare was in full effect e.g. the blood splatter and the frizbee moving in slow motion through the air. the gun fight being affected by the moon was genius too. completely loved everything about it. one of the best of the year.
This is a very weak Johnnie To movie. The style can't overcome the lack of substance.
I'm becoming ambivalent about To lately as his style is, while very enjoyable, often becoming too repetitive. Like Capra, Ford, and Tarentino, his movies have become incredibly predictable; essentially a subgenre within the HK film industry.
I haven't heard anything positive about this film until this review. Does the reviewer think that what To tried to do with a new actor and directing within the language divide lead to anything new? I enjoyed "Sparrow" in large part because it seemed to unite both the choreography and playfulness of MGM musicals within the To traditional neo-noir model.
Does Vengeance seem more like the To produced films "Eye in the Sky", "Accident" or "Tactical Unit: Comrades in Arms" or is it more like a To production with all the stylistic flourishes? The review suggests "Vengeance" is more of the latter.
Funnily just finsihed it and I loved every minute of it.
Vengeance somehow reminded me of Takeshi Kitano's Brother. The visual style on spot, different feel, different movie. But I loved it.
My copy of the DVD arrived Saturday, and I watched it over the weekend. I must concur that Vengeance is not a very good Johnnie To film, though it is by no means a poor film. It is still a much better filmed and more tightly narrated than many other HK productions. The film appears to contain painfully forced sequences with flashes of brilliance in equal parts. Not one of To's better films, but certainly still worth watching. Plus, it's good to see Fung Shui-Fan on screen again.
Most of the reviews Throw Down had, at least the ones i had seen, put it as a barely average movie, and is one of my all time favorite films. My point being: almost everytime a To movie gets a bad to average review it ends up being a fantastic movie. Just Mad Detective truly felt a bit of a mixed bag.
Just watched it last night. Two inventive action sequences (especially the the moon sequence!) and having the main character begin to forget why he's seeking revenge in the first place make this worth watching. There are other nice little touches throughout but overall this film is mediocre at best. The editing needed to be tightened up in a few places which would've helped with some moments where the acting was lacking. Liked it more than I thought I would after reading so many negative comments about it.
If you watch Mad Detective a couple times it's brilliant, the complicated story is very well told visually and through the editing. One of To's best that seems to be underrated. Throw Down is still my favorite though.
Meh. just finished it 2 minutes ago. First half is very entertaining, the second is just boring.I thought the plot device concerning our protagonist's memory loss was completely absurd, throwing the movie into a tailspin into MEMENTO rip-off territory.
The movie's got mad style,but almost every other aspect of it was garbage.