I understand fully that the point of being critical about a Hollywood film about Ninjas could be considered by some to be an exercise in futility. Really. Did anyone expect this to be good? I just really want to take the piss out of someone today and stretch my fingers. Ninja Assassin, you're my bitch tonight. You're just another example of Hollywood Action Film Making 101 and you con viewers into thinking they are watching something exciting and action packed. You're not. You're silly. You're rather boring. And you're another fine example of why bigger and louder doesn't mean better.
I guess when you're part of the Wachowski/Silver family your indoctrinated into the art of Bullet Time. McTeigue had already 'dazzled' us with Dagger Time in V for Vendetta and this time around he gave us Shuraken Time. I can't wait for Falling Flower Pot Time or Wife Throwing Dishes Time. Domestic violence will have never looked so good.
Damn this film was poorly lit. I understand the whole thing about Ninjas using the dark and it would have been easy to ask if anyone ever thought about turning on the lights but it would also appear that Ninjas are also master electricians and can eliminate partial city blocks just to carry out their deadly plans. The trouble of course is that McTeigue could use this to his advantage and hide from us that he really doesn't have a fucking clue what he is doing when it comes to framing his action scenes. Perhaps it was so dark he himself couldn't see what he was shooting. That's why it would appear that he got too close to his subjects. Was that it James? Just say yes and I'll forgive you.
A lot of the Asian actors spoke slowly as if they were on Valium, probably because they couldn't believe the dialogue they had been given to speak. And Rain was limited to sentences no more than between 4 to 6 words when you could see his lips move. Nice one on the boy band line though. That went completely over the heads of everyone in the theatre who don't know who Rain is outside of this role.
I commend everyone for all the hard work they put into the film. May I suggest it would have been easier on themselves if they simplified their shooting schedule, shot less, edited less. And think of all the money you would have saved on film stock and processing fees. The money you would have saved on labor costs and equipment rentals and catering costs. The less shots you preconceive for your film the less time you need to film it the less time you need everyone around. But the editor especially needs to be recognized for meeting more than the quota of five editors combined in this film. Truly you are at the top of your game when you can edit the swing of a sword from 15 individual shots.
Everyone worked overtime on this one editing the crap out of it and adding geysers of computer generated blood wherever they could except the floor- for the most part it would seem. Someone needs to talk to those fellas about the laws of physics and gravity. That blood had to fall somewhere. Tatami mats must be extra absorbent for such a reason. That being said I wasn't expecting this film to be this gory. Lots of limbs. When you have this many guys in pajamas swinging swords around widly someone is going to get knicked. But yeah, props for limbs and gore. Just work on that blood a bit more. You got your R rating. Well deserved. Too bad that's gonna hurt your box office take. 14 year olds around the world are firing up their browsers as we speak.
There was one scene in the climactic battle, you know, where the highly sensitive ninjas couldn't hear the humvees pull up outside the walls of their compound or the giant Chinook helicopters coming down the valley. Mountains reverberate sound dingbats! There was a scene where it looked like McTeigue conceded to pull the camera back far enough to let us see what the fuck was going on. Looked like. I want to say that Rain could handle himself with a sword but McTeigue made the rather odd choice of zooming right up to Rain, I guess to show the expressions of determination on his face, while the cutting and action happened just off screen. You could tell because there was more of that CGI blood spraying stage left or right.
I didn't have any expectations for Ninja Assassin. I go to screenings like this on the off chance that I am surprised and delighted by the end product. Sadly, this movie is just another sorry example of action film making from Hollywood. In their right hand they distract us with the shiny throwing star while with their left hand they're punching us in the pills.
More from Ninja Assassin
- Interviews: Rain and James McTeigue Talk NINJA ASSASSIN
- Reviews: NINJA ASSASSIN Review
- Reviews: FF 2009 Review. Ninja Assassin
- Mastheads: Ninja Assassin
- Mastheads: Ninja Assassin
- Mastheads: Ninja Assassin
- Mastheads: Ninja Assassin
- Mastheads: Ninja Assassin
- Mastheads: Ninja Assassin
- Mastheads: Ninja Assassin
- Mastheads: Ninja Assassin
- Mastheads: Ninja Assassin
- Mastheads: Ninja Assassin
- Mastheads: Ninja Assassin
- Mastheads: Ninja Assassin


I have to completely agree. I also went into this screening with no expectations and it was still just awful. I wanted to give it a chance but it just got worse and worse.
Ouch!
Damn, for all their faults I do expect the Wachowskis to come up with something better than what you just described. Generally speaking I really like what they're doing, and I thought "Speed Racer" was a pretty unique vision that took a lot of daring to pull off...
A shame, the stunt reel showed that Rain has real physical talent and the stunt team real creativity. Sounds like that reel is more satisfying than the movie. I personally don't mind messing with time and speed, even a few mid-move edits as long as those edits serve the purpose of elucidating the movements (e.g. Ching Siu-tung in his prime). But editing the action into incoherency kills it. Sounds like another case where true action talent is squandered and undercut by the filmmakers.
Oh well, at least we have Florentine's Ninja to look forward to.
Also, what's up with people shooting action too dark to see clearly? I've noticed that a lot in recent trailers, although I'm always hoping it is just the trailer mastering / encoding and not representative of the film.
true this movie is really dark. Though the action is good. And it is interesting.
"a lot of the Asian actors spoke slowly" are they suppose to speak fast or something?
"Nice one on the boy band line though." WTF are you kidding me. i guess you got it right.
The law of physics and gravity.... its a ninja movie. are you kidding me. there are guys hanging upside down on ceiling going invisible healing themselves... and you worry about the blood!?
these guys in pajamas are NINJA you fool.... and they swing there swords wildly cause you know what you are looking at! for a critic you sure suck
you came in this movie to bag on it. you hate the way Americans make action movies. hmmm tell me how they can make the movie better!
I believe I wrote.... oh where is it... ah there it is! "I didn't have any expectations for Ninja Assassin. I go to screenings like this on the off chance that I am surprised and delighted by the end product". You see? I didn't go in ready to "bag on it" but with no expectations at all and let the film speak for itself. It didn't say much.
"...are they suppose to speak fast or something?" It sounded labored. Hooray for Rain and his trying to break into Hollywood. God knows why he wants to do that. But when there are many, many young Asian American actors who can speak not only fluently but fluidly I would have gone that route as not to change the flow of dialogue so abruptly.
"...and you worry about the blood!?" I do. I worry about blood a lot! It is one of my greatest concerns in life, along with taxes, world peace and finding a good place to eat on a Friday night.
"these guys in pajamas are NINJA you fool..." Der! The pajamas thing was meant to be sarcastic and funny. Sigh.
wow you replied.. that's pretty crazy.
You spoke enough to let me think you hate the movie from grounds ups. from the director to the editing. thats fine though its your job. but thats pretty crazy if you thought that movie didn't say much. Give me a movie that says a lot that is in the same criteria as this one.
Maybe they spoke slowly like on Valium because to make it more.....Asian...can i say that? maybe they did it cause we are used to ninjas or asian assassins to speak like that... a fluently speaking ninja and ninja master... i would actually think make the movie maybe more understandably but less ....hmmmm movie realistic.. if there is such a thing. can you imagine them all speaking just normal just like everyone else in there little panamas in barefoot swinging there swords wildly at each other. doesn't fit into my NINJA... even if in real life there are ninja or whatever that do speak fluent english.
The blood. i cant say much you have pointed out everything else you have worried about that doesn't have to do anything with movies. So i really don't know where you are going with that.
"these guys in pajamas are NINJA you fool..." i thought it was just funny to put that in. if you didn't get my sarcasm yourself.
Thank you for responding though. Made my day.