Shadow: Dead Riot

Sakuran Review

by Niels Matthijs, July 31, 2009 12:25 PM


While there are many films about the life of the samurai, the world of geishas seems less penetrable for filmmakers. Not too long ago there was of course Memoires of a Geisha, but with a Western Hollywood director and Chinese lead actress fronting the film is was hard to take it serious. Not that Sakuran presents a historically correct representation of the geisha, but if you're looking for a Japanese alternative, Sakuran will give you a funky look into the lives of the former Japanese class prostitutes.

Find out after the break why you should not miss out on this one.

Sakuran is based on a manga, though presents itself a little different from most other manga adaptations. Of course you shouldn't expect a historical drama, but you will find a less comical and fluffy approach than seen in most manga adaptations. The film is helmed by Mika Ninagawa, raised as photographer and turned director, and clearly eager to bring her previous work experience to the film. Her direction is key in making this film into something more than just a quircky, funny manga-based flick, giving it plenty of extra flair and turning Sakuran into a unique experience.

The story follows the typical geisha structure, starting with a young girl being sold to a geisha house. She is pretty enough for the job and is taught the ways of the geisha. More than simple sex slaves, good geishas are learned in the arts and should be able to boast their talents. Poetry, dance and singing are all equally important parts of what they do. Miyako is particularly good at the job and quickly rises as one of the star prostitutes, much to the envy of her mentor. Still, Miyako is unable to enjoy her life of empty luxury and shallow entertainment, and longs for her freedom.

The basics of the film aren't too earth shattering, and if you happened to run into a geisha film before chances are that you are already familiar with the outline of the story. Miyako is played by Tsuchiya, perfectly cast for this role, though she might risk being type-casted if she continues to take on similar roles. Miyako is in some ways a reprise of her role in Kamikaze Girls, only a little downplayed because of her character's profession. Still, she fits in perfectly, with her less than perfect geisha-like behavior and often devilish look. Kanno plays a good adversary, the rest of the cast is decent enough but aren't too busy as the focus of the film lies mainly with Miyako and her mentor.

Visually though, this film is something else. From the first frames it is obvious that Ninagawa has a keen eye and doesn't go easy on the colors. The film is drenched in bold reds and isn't afraid to overload the frames with a clash of color if needed. Settings, costumes and lighting all play their part in making this one of the most boldly colored films I have seen in a long time. The effect is mesmerizing and is consequently carried out throughout the whole film, never allowing a dull shot or frame to enter the film. The music is also a little different, featuring more modern sounds which in any other circumstance would clash horribly with the historical setting. But because the film is already bursting from your screen, this modern approach works and helps to set it apart from its peers a little more. That said, I don't think the soundtrack was perfect, probably a little too poppy in places, but the effect was nice enough alright.

Sakuran is a cool film, if only because it gives you something worth looking at for its entire running time. The drama is rather typical, the acting is good, but these are not the big selling points of the film as it doesn't outclass many other good films on these points. The visuals is why people will remember this film, and if you like your films with lively colors, Sakuran is not to be missed for sure. A fun, quirky but solid and stylistic manga adaptation, it's good to see they are still being made, as I've been a little disappointed with recent efforts coming from Japan.


At Mubi

6 Comments

user-pic

I don't want to sound like a purist twat but this movie is about oirans, not geisha. There are a lot of similarities between the two but they are different.

user-pic

Bellmer's Doll is absolutely right, oiran are a completely different thing from geisha who were never prostitutes but 'women of the arts.'

That said, the review is otherwise spot-on. I took a chance on this movie by ordering the DVD from Japan a year or two ago. Thankfully, I wasn't disappointed. it's an eye-popping treat of a film. The director is principally a photographer by profession and it really shows in the visuals and saturated colours. The music referred to, by the way, is all by Shiina Ringo, Japan's most credible female singer/musician.

A great movie to show off your TV's capabilities and enjoyable with it. Best of all, in the UK you can buy it from Amazon for about £8-98. (I paid £20 getting it from Japan and it was still worth every yen!)

user-pic

I don't know anything about mangas or manga culture so I experienced this lovely film without any of that connective tissue. It is a visual explosion.

(I too was a little weirded out by the reviewer's freely interchanging geisha and prostitute, when that's not really true or accurate of what's going on here, but ... the rest is very good)

user-pic

I got the Taiwanese edition of this film which is a nice, reasonably DVD set in a big cardboard box. No English subs on the extras but a nice package.

No mention of the songs and music by Shiina Ringo?

user-pic

Yeah, I hate to be pedantic, but the confusion of oiran (prostitutes) and geisha (artisan-entertainers) is a big enough deal that you should really consider editing this article.

It’s been said many times before in many places, so I’m really at a loss as to why the misunderstanding still persists in some sectors of Western culture, but geisha (or geiko) and maiko are. not. prostitutes. And in spite of what some might say, Arthur Golden’s distasteful and preposterous novel is not at all a reliable source of information on their history or culture.

user-pic

I'm sorry bout the mix up, but it's the first time I hear about the difference between the two. It's probably a very big deal for people who are a bit more involved with it, but I don't really see a need for editing. Will make sure to not make the same mistake in the future though!


Related Posts with Thumbnails