John Rabe

TIFF Report: Exiled Review

by Todd Brown, September 9, 2006 3:55 AM


exiled.jpg

[TIFF info page here.]

While I hesitate to label Johnnie To’s Exiled a masterpiece I do so only because it is playing in this festival opposite his Election films, films which surpass this one in terms of social criticism, both of which clearly merit that label themselves. Suffice it to say that To is on a hot streak right now. A very, very hot streak.

Bearing all the marks of a film created as raw entertainment to cleanse the palette after the grim ride of the back to back Election features, Exiled is the much rumored quasi-sequel to The Mission. And let’s clear those rumors up right now. While it shares a cast and a similar tone with The Mission the cast here are playing entirely different characters, so Mission-reunion yes, but Mission sequel no.

The film opens with a fist pounding on a door, opened by a run down woman with a baby squalling in the background. “Does Wo live here?” "There's no such person," she replies, clearly lying, and the pair of searchers, ominously well dressed for such a run down neighborhood, move off to a nearby square to wait. Two minutes later and the exact same scenario is played out again with a new pair of searching eyes at the door. They also move to the square to wait and it soons becomes clear that our two pairs are old friends, albeit friends now found on opposite sides. Though now marked by split loyalties the four hitmen are all childhood friends of Wo, himself an exiled gangster now unwisely returned to Macau on the eve of its return to Chinese control. Realizing the danger their friend is in, the first pair has come to protect him. Ordered by their boss to do so, the second pair has come to kill him.

Where to even begin with what Exiled does well? Let's start with To himself. The film is simply gorgeous to look at, the cinematography just stunning capturing a seemingly endless stream of iconic images. While it is tempting to label it a simple triad-action film To has much larger designs than that, filling the film with an unusual grace and beauty, a playful sense of humor, and a concern for his characters that runs well beyond when they've got their guns in their hands with his approach to story strongly reminiscent of Takeshi Kitano's Sonatine at times, albeit a much prettier, much more violent Sonatine.

Move on to the action. To has a loyal following among Hong Kong action fans for very good reason, he is simply one of the most technically accomplished film makers working in Hong Kong today. You may well think you've seen every possible gunplay option Hong Kong has to offer. To proves you wrong. He does it early, he does it often. There are shots in this film that will leave your jaw on the floor for their sheer inventiveness and style.

Move to the script. When To falters it is most often a lack of attention to his characters that brings him down. This is not even remotely a problem here. His characters are rich and unique, the motivations run deep, the plot line clever and engaging while never losing site of the people that drive it. While the film appears to stray from the main thread in the middle going you soon realize that what To is doing is fleshing out his characters as full blooded people and when he easily and masterfully pulls his players back to the main story line it gives the ending that final wallop.

And finally, the cast. Francis Ng. Simon Yam. Lam Suet. Anthony Wong. Nick Cheung. Not only has To assembled the hardest of the Hong Kong hard men for his gangster drama, but every one of them is also a very fine actor in his own right. Upping the ante further is the simple fact that To and his crew have worked with these same actors repeatedly over the years, many of them appearing in several To helmed films together, which gives them the natural, easy rapport that elevates the proceedings so far above the norm. Smart and crackling with energy though it may be Exiled feels like nothing so much as a group of old friends getting together to play and having a simply fantastic time while doing it.

Don't mistake the praise here. Exiled is not a serious film in the way Election is a serious film. This is not To making a statement. This is To in full on entertainment mode and he succeeds mightily in that regard. Just a little over a year ago I was well prepared to write To off after a string of films that simply failed to engage whatsoever. But between the Election films and now Exiled one thing is very clear: Johnnie To is simply the most vital, muscular figure in Hong Kong cinema today and he deserves comparison to the all time greats.


At Mubi

13 Comments

user-pic

might consider going to TIFF for this, since it's the only interesting film that hasn't sold out yet.

user-pic

If you can get a ticket, Will, it's absolutely worth it. Look for the door sequence in the opening gun fight. You'll know it when you see it. Damn.

user-pic

So I take it you're officially off the Johnnie To hating bandwagon?

Heh.

user-pic

Yup. I'd been ready to write him off entirely before Election, but this is three DAMN good films in a row from him ...

user-pic

Hey Todd, have you seen/did you like The Mission or Fulltime Killer?

user-pic

"Exiled" is a sophistocated, really successful film -a ballet of bullets, a sympthony of sounds. It has a long, long arc with a satisfying rhythm from the first shot to the last. The score and soundscape are original and effective - this guy understands the power of all kinds of sounds - rattles, breathing, spent bullet casings hitting the floor, Portuguese music, American Western tunes - and the power of silence.
The characters and shoot-outs are larger than life,and matched by the blackness of the humor and ineptitude of the gangsters

While you watch this highly stylized violence it's not disturbing because not for a moment is it real. However, that gunman in Montreal yesterday, who brought mayhem and death to the halls of Dawson College, said he "wanted to go out in a hail of bullets". He may have imagined himself in a Johnnie To movie. But in real life, there's nothing balletic or beautiful about a shoot-out, it's merely banal. The banality of evil.

user-pic

I was blown away by this film. Its become one of my favorite "westerns" ever.

user-pic

thanks for the review. You might want to change "Exiled 1+2" to "Election 1+2" at the top to avoid confusion

user-pic

D'oh... thanks for catching that. It's fixed now.

user-pic

I think all of us would agree that this is a step in the right direction for HK cinema. SPL was very good and I think that Exiled is a better realized film than that. Deeper and well rounded there is a lot more meat to Exiled than SPL. Both movies remind us how great HK cinema can be. Will the rest of HK follow? Time will tell.

user-pic

This movie is gonna rock. Can't wait.

user-pic

It was the most purely fun film I've seen this year, and I will certainly own a copy the second it is put out on DVD. If this movie comes to the cinema anywhere near you, gather a group of friends, especially those who loved the heyday of HK cinema in the late 80s early 90s...FANTASTIC STUFF from To!

-----
user-pic

Seeing EXILED AT TIFF was my 1st Johnnie To film.And I'd have to say it felt like I got my cherry popped or doing crack for the 1st time. This film is wonderful. Yes their were times when my jaw was on the floor I couldn't believe what I was seeing. Very stylish and the soundtrack was awsome. I am now a big fan my soxs were knox off.

-----

Related Posts with Thumbnails