NYAFF Hangover: UNITED RED ARMY Review
The New York Asian Film Festival completed another successful run more than two weeks ago. By all rights, this review should have run before United Red Army had its North American Premiere on the fest's last day, but it took me this long to wrap my head fully around it. My apologies. I an currently self-criticizing my actions.
The dates, facts, and figures come flying out of the introductory section of United Red Army like a machine gun, accompanied by a hypnotic musical theme, shooting down any possible suspicion that director Kôji Wakamatsu intended to make an audience-friendly film about the Japanese student movement of the late 60s and early 70s.
Indeed, the tone is so strident that you feel guilty for not taking notes, as though a class were being taught and you were not properly prepared to answer questions asked by the deep-voiced narrator. Initially fascinating, the tone and pace becomes off-putting, frustrating, and finally wearisome. Suddenly, though, you notice that Wakamatsu has been sneaking in brief dramatizations of the student movement's evolution that have grown longer each time they break up the narrated documentary footage. Almost before you realize it, you're caught up in a brutally gripping dilemma facing sincere individuals.
In short, you face the same situation as the real-life characters depicted in the film.
By the point of immersion, we're trapped in an isolated mountain cabin in the dead of winter, trying to withstand the shouting screaming fury of the leaders of the United Red Army, formed from two separate militant groups with the common goal in mind of "Revolution!"
The leaders are so laser-beam focused on their ideals, of the absolute raging requirement that only strictly trained individuals are qualified to be in the movement, that they elevate the requirement of "self-criticism" beyond what any human can bear. It's not even clear that the leaders themselves understand what "self-criticism" involves. It becomes an agonizing, appalling riddle within an enigman: if you have to ask how to "self-criticize," you're obviously not qualified to be a member of the group until you know how to "self-criticize." Don't worry, though, no matter what you do it'll never be harsh enough to qualify as "self-criticism" in the eyes of the leaders.
Round after round we go, with one young person after another failing to live up to the ideal and facing elimination at the hands of their fellow former comrades.
It spoils none of the movie's power to say that it concludes with a lengthy reenactment of the last few surviving members of the group holed up in a mountain lodge, holding the hapless female proprietor hostage as the police attempt to bring a peaceful resolution to the stand-off. It's all told from within the lodge, and feels just as claustrophobic and tense as the seemingly endless rounds of attempted "self-criticism" in the isolated cabin.
The festival program notes say that Wakamatsu "knew many of the members of the Red Army factions, some of whom fled to North Korea, some of whom went to Palestine and some of whom are in the US (a Red Army member was arrested carrying bomb-making materials on the New Jersey turnpike in 1988)" and that the director based the film "on extensive research, interviews with surviving and jailed Red Army faction members and his own memories and friendships."
United Red Army is not a warm and cuddly nostalgic trip. It's not a hippie radical remembering "the good old days." It's vicious and cold, hard and heartless, sad and sorrowful. It's ghastly and it's haunting and it's probably too long and it's probably too easy for some people to dismiss as alarmist.
But, man, does it cut like a knife.